Skip to content

Vaginal probiotics: What are they and how do they work?

Published · Automatically source-checked · By Tigoo redaktionSupplements

Short answer

Vaginal probiotics are live microorganisms studied for a vaginal or urogenital use case, and the strain plus route matter. The body of evidence is narrow: the clearest findings are for specific products, not for all probiotics sold for women.

Quick facts

  • A vaginal probiotic is a live strain studied for vaginal or urogenital use, not just a wellness label.
  • Oral supplements, vaginal products and fermented foods are not interchangeable.
  • The clearest BV evidence was for vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 after metronidazole.
  • Strain identity, CFU, storage and expiry all matter.
  • Safety reports were mostly local or digestive side effects; recurrent or unexplained symptoms need assessment.
Vaginal probiotics: What are they and how do they work?

What are vaginal probiotics, exactly?

Live microorganisms, not a label

In the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements definition, a probiotic is a live microorganism given in an adequate amount that confers a health benefit, and the organism should be identified to the strain level. In this article, “vaginal probiotic” means a live strain studied for a vaginal or urogenital use case, not just a product sold under a wellness label. NIH ODS probiotic fact sheet

That distinction matters because a product marketed “for women” can still be a general oral probiotic aimed at digestion, while a vaginal product is studied by route and outcome. ODS says probiotics generally act in the digestive tract, and it also notes that not every fermented food contains a probiotic with demonstrated benefit. NIH ODS consumer fact sheet

What a healthy vaginal microbiome often looks like

In a study of 396 asymptomatic North American women of reproductive age, about 73% had vaginal communities in which Lactobacillus accounted for more than half of bacterial sequences. Communities dominated by L. crispatus had a median pH of about 4.0, versus 5.3 in a more diverse, non-Lactobacillus-dominated group; L. iners, L. gasseri, and L. jensenii also dominated distinct groups. Vaginal microbiome study in reproductive-age women

The practical takeaway is narrow but useful: a vagina with fewer Lactobacillus sequences is not, by itself, a diagnosis of infection. The same study found that the women with more diverse communities were still asymptomatic, so a probiotic label cannot be read as a substitute for knowing what microbial pattern was actually studied. Vaginal microbiome study in reproductive-age women

Oral supplements, vaginal products, and fermented foods are different forms

FormHow it is usedWhat the evidence here supports
Oral supplementSwallowedStudied as a digestive-tract product unless a trial specifically tested vaginal outcomes. NIH ODS probiotic fact sheet
Vaginal capsule or suppositoryInserted intravaginallyStudied as a vaginal formulation, with route and schedule defined in the trial. Lactin-V trial
Fermented foodConsumed as foodMay contain live cultures, but ODS says not every fermented food contains a probiotic with a proven benefit. NIH ODS consumer fact sheet
A “for women” probiotic is not automatically a vaginal probiotic; the route, the strain, and the studied use all have to match.

So the label alone is not enough. For a vaginal probiotic, the useful questions are: what live strain is named, was it studied orally or vaginally, and was it tested for a vaginal outcome rather than for general digestive use? NIH ODS probiotic fact sheet

How do they work in the vagina?

Acid production and pH are the clearest proposed effects

Vaginal lactobacilli are thought to work mainly by producing lactic acid, which helps keep the vaginal environment acidic and may make conditions less favourable for some competing organisms. In a study of 396 asymptomatic North American women of reproductive age, communities dominated by Lactobacillus had a lower median pH when L. crispatus was the main species: about 4.0 versus 5.3 in a more diverse, non-Lactobacillus-dominated group (vaginal microbiome study). The same dataset also showed distinct dominant groups for L. iners, L. gasseri and L. jensenii, which is one reason researchers do not treat all “probiotics” as interchangeable. NIH’s probiotic fact sheet says a probiotic has to be a live microorganism identified to the strain level (NIH ODS probiotic fact sheet).

How do they work in the vagina?
Vaginal lactobacilli are thought to work mainly by producing lactic acid, which helps keep the vaginal environment acidic and may make conditions less favourable for some competing organisms.

Adhesion and competition appear to be strain-specific

Another proposed mechanism is that certain strains attach to vaginal cells and compete with other microbes for space. In laboratory screening of 100 isolates from healthy premenopausal women, selected L. crispatus and L. jensenii strains adhered to vaginal epithelial cells and displaced Gardnerella vaginalis or Candida albicans under test conditions (microbiology study). That same work found that hydrogen-peroxide activity alone did not sufficiently inhibit C. albicans, which is a useful warning against assuming one laboratory marker explains every strain’s behaviour.

The key biological point is strain specificity: a named species does not guarantee the same vaginal effect in every product.

Vaginal delivery and oral delivery are studied differently

Local vaginal delivery places the live strain at the target site more directly, while oral products are studied separately and cannot be assumed to behave the same way. In the Lactin-V trial, women received vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 at 2 billion CFU per application; the trial strain was detected in 79% of treated participants at week 12 and 48% at week 24 (Lactin-V trial). By contrast, in a small pregnancy study, none of the analysed women had detectable vaginal colonisation by strains from a six-species oral capsule after roughly four months (trial summary).

RouteWhat was studiedWhat was seen
VaginalL. crispatus CTV-05, 2 billion CFU per applicationDetected in 79% at week 12 and 48% at week 24
OralSix-species capsule taken by mouthNo detectable vaginal colonisation in the analysed pregnancy study

That is why mechanism evidence comes from microbiology, vaginal microbiome studies and clinical trials, not from generic probiotic theory alone. The route, the strain and the measured outcome all matter (clinical trial evidence; microbiome study).

What does the research actually support?

The clearest evidence is for one narrow bacterial vaginosis setup, not for vaginal probiotics as a class. In a randomized trial of 228 women aged 18–45 who had completed metronidazole, vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 for 11 weeks was followed by recurrence by week 12 in 30% of the probiotic group versus 45% of placebo, with follow-up through week 24 (trial report). A broader review of 10 randomized BV-recurrence trials involving 1,234 premenopausal women found oral and vaginal products, multiple strains, and tested doses from 1.0–5.4 billion CFU orally and 40,000–8.0 billion CFU vaginally, but it could not identify an optimal route or dose (systematic review).

The research signal is strongest for one specific post-antibiotic BV regimen, while the wider probiotic category remains formulation-specific and inconsistent.
ConditionMost informative evidenceWhat it showedMain limit
Bacterial vaginosis228 women aged 18–45; vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 after metronidazole (PMC)30% recurrence with CTV-05 versus 45% with placebo by week 12Does not make every vaginal probiotic interchangeable
Vulvovaginal candidiasis14 randomized studies through October 2025 (PubMed)Low or very-low certainty; long-term benefit unclear
Recurrent urinary tract infections174 women in one trial, plus a small post-UTI recurrence study (PubMed)Mixed recurrence results across routesToo few and too different studies for a firm routine recommendation

Evidence for recurrent urinary tract infections is thinner and more mixed. In one trial of 174 premenopausal women, four-month symptomatic-UTI incidence was 70.4% with placebo, 61.3% with oral probiotics, 40.9% with vaginal probiotics and 31.8% with both routes; a smaller trial after acute UTI found recurrence in 15% with vaginal CTV-05 versus 27% with placebo, but the confidence interval crossed no difference (trial report). A 2026 review found only four randomized trials involving 616 women and could not pool them because the studies were too different (systematic review).

What this means for routine use

Across these conditions, the pattern is the same: one or two promising trial results, then a wider literature that is smaller, more heterogeneous, and less decisive. That is why the evidence is strongest for a specific strain, route and post-treatment schedule in BV, weaker for recurrent UTI prevention, and still not strong enough to turn vaginal probiotics into a general routine recommendation for every woman or every symptom pattern (PMC trial; review).

EU claim status

In the EU context, the retrieved EFSA meeting record lists a proposed claim for L. crispatus BCCM/LMG P 17631 and defence against vaginal pathogens, but the record itself does not show an authorised health claim (EFSA meeting record). For readers, that means the research remains strain-specific and product-specific rather than a broad claim for all vaginal probiotics.

Which strains and forms matter most?

The main strains studied

The best-known vaginal-health trials have not tested a generic “probiotic” category. They have tested named strains, often from the Lactobacillus group, including L. crispatus CTV-05, L. rhamnosus GR-1, L. reuteri RC-14, L. fermentum LF10, and L. acidophilus LA02. A review of 10 randomised BV-recurrence trials found oral products in three trials and vaginal products in seven, with species that also included L. crispatus, L. rhamnosus and L. reuteri among others. The point is specificity: a product labelled “Lactobacillus” is not the same as a product naming a strain such as CTV-05 or RC-14. PMC review of Lactin-V and related trials BV recurrence meta-analysis

Which strains and forms matter most?
The best-known vaginal-health trials have not tested a generic “probiotic” category.
Studied formHow it is deliveredExample from trialsWhat the evidence does and does not show
Oral capsuleSwallowed and intended to pass through the gut before any vaginal effect is assessedL. rhamnosus GR-1 plus L. reuteri RC-14 used orally at 1 billion CFU of each strain, twice daily for 30 days in one BV trialOral use is not interchangeable with a vaginal product, and different trials using the same named strains did not all show the same result. Oral GR-1/RC-14 BV trial
Vaginal capsule / applicatorPlaced locally to reach the vaginal site directlyL. crispatus CTV-05 (Lactin-V) at 2 billion CFU per application for 11 weeks after metronidazoleThis is the clearest single-strain vaginal regimen in the retrieved evidence, but it is evidence for one product, one schedule, and one studied population. Lactin-V trial
Vaginal tablet / slow-release productDesigned for local release over timeL. fermentum LF10 plus L. acidophilus LA02, with at least 0.4 billion live cells of each strain per tabletMulti-strain formats exist, but the presence of more than one strain is not proof of greater usefulness. Slow-release vaginal tablet study

CFU, strain identity, and storage are practical details, not guarantees

CFU means colony-forming units, a count of viable microorganisms in the product; it is not a measure of how well a product will work. In the BV trials reviewed, tested doses ranged from 1.0–5.4 billion CFU orally and 40,000–8.0 billion CFU vaginally, which shows how wide the study range is. NIH’s Office of Dietary Supplements says viable counts can fall during storage, so the label should specify CFU through shelf life, not only at manufacture. A larger CFU number does not automatically mean a better outcome. NIH ODS probiotics fact sheet BV recurrence trial review

The most useful label is the one that names the exact strain, route, and CFU per dose; “multi-strain” alone is not a quality marker.

Why route matters

Route and product design are part of the evidence. In the Lactin-V study, the administered strain was detected vaginally in 79% of participants at week 12, while an oral six-species capsule study in pregnancy found no detectable vaginal colonisation by the analysed strains after roughly four months. The practical lesson is simple: oral capsules, vaginal capsules, gels, pessaries, and tablets are not interchangeable, even when they contain bacteria from the same genus. Lactin-V trial and review

How do you choose the best one for your goal?

Start with the goal, because the evidence is not a class-wide “vaginal probiotic” story. For prevention of recurrence after bacterial vaginosis treatment, the clearest individual trial was vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 after metronidazole in 228 women aged 18–45, using 2 billion CFU per applicator on an 11-week schedule; BV recurred by week 12 in 30% versus 45% on placebo. Randomized Lactin-V trial

For an adjunct during antibiotics, the oral route has also been studied: in 125 premenopausal Nigerian women with BV, L. rhamnosus GR-1 plus L. A different 126-woman Chinese trial using the same named strains orally found no day-30 improvement. Oral BV adjunct trial

A review of 10 randomized BV-recurrence trials found both oral and vaginal products, with tested daily doses ranging from 1.0–5.4 billion CFU orally and 40,000–8.0 billion CFU vaginally; it could not identify an optimal route or dose. BV recurrence review

What to check on the label

  • Full strain designation: genus, species, and strain, not just “Lactobacillus.” NIH ODS says probiotic effects are strain-specific. NIH ODS probiotic guidance
  • Route: oral products and vaginal products are not interchangeable. NIH ODS probiotic guidance
  • Expiry and storage instructions: ODS advises looking for CFU guaranteed through the end of shelf life, because viable counts can fall. NIH ODS consumer guidance
GoalClosest studied patternLabel details to match
Recurrence after BV antibioticsVaginal L. crispatus CTV-05, 2 billion CFU per applicator, after metronidazoleExact strain, vaginal route, applicator dose, storage, expiry
Antibiotic-adjunct useOral GR-1 + RC-14 with metronidazole in one trialExact strains, oral route, CFU per strain, timing
General shoppingNo universal best product establishedStrain ID, route, shelf-life CFU, storage

What not to infer from the front of the box

Higher CFU does not automatically mean better results, and a longer ingredient list does not prove superiority. The evidence repeatedly shows that outcomes depend on the exact strain, route, and schedule, not on a glossy “women’s health” claim. NIH ODS probiotic guidance Lactin-V trial

The best choice is the product whose strain, route, and dosing pattern most closely match the studied goal.

How should you take them to get the best chance of benefit?

Match the schedule to the studied product

The practical rule from the trials is not “take any probiotic,” but “use the exact strain, route and schedule that was studied.” In the BV trial, vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 was started after metronidazole, while other studies used oral products alongside metronidazole or after fluconazole for thrush. An oral capsule is not the same as a vaginal product, and ODS notes that viable counts can fall during shelf life, so storage and use-by instructions matter too. ODS Probiotics fact sheet

How should you take them to get the best chance of benefit?
The practical rule from the trials is not “take any probiotic,” but “use the exact strain, route and schedule that was studied.
Studied situationStudied timing and routePractical takeaway
BV after metronidazoleVaginal L. crispatus CTV-05, 2 billion CFU per applicator; four daily doses, then twice weekly for 10 weeksDo not shorten or convert this to an oral product and assume it is the same regimen. Trial details
BV with oral probioticsL. rhamnosus GR-1 plus L. reuteri RC-14, 1 billion CFU of each strain twice daily for 30 days, given with metronidazole in one trialDifferent trial, different route, different schedule. The same named strains did not perform the same way in another study. Trial details
Thrush adjunct studyOral GR-1 plus RC-14 after a single 150 mg fluconazole doseDo not treat this as a generic “women’s probiotic” rule. Trial details

Keep use consistent long enough to match the study

The clearest BV regimen ran for 11 weeks, and the administered strain was still detected in 79% of treated participants at week 12 and 48% at week 24. That does not mean every product behaves the same way, but it does show why short, irregular use is not the same as a trial schedule. In the same study, adherence was measured at 77% by returned-applicator assessment and 81% by self-report, so taking doses as directed was part of the tested regimen. Lactin-V trial

Do not improvise a new regimen from a headline: the route, strain, dose and duration all have to match the study product. PMC trial evidence

Common mistakes that make results harder to interpret

  • Using a generic “women’s probiotic” instead of the full genus, species and strain listed in the study or label. ODS Probiotics fact sheet
  • Switching products every few days, which makes it impossible to follow a studied schedule. Trial regimens
  • Stopping early because symptoms change, rather than completing the course that was actually tested. Trial regimens
  • Putting food or an ordinary oral supplement into the vagina instead of using a formulated vaginal product; NHS guidance advises against applying yogurt or probiotics for thrush. NHS guidance
  • Self-managing repeated symptoms without diagnosis; persistent or recurrent symptoms should be assessed rather than used as a reason to keep changing products. PMC evidence

ODS also notes that antibiotics or antifungals might reduce the effectiveness of some probiotics, but it does not establish a universal spacing rule, so there is no evidence-based reason to invent one. ODS Immune Function fact sheet

Can food or lifestyle help the vaginal microbiome?

Fermented foods: studied, but not interchangeable with vaginal probiotic products

Foods with live cultures have been studied, mainly as yogurt or yogurt drinks, but they are not the same thing as a clinically studied vaginal probiotic strain, route, and dose. NIH’s Office of Dietary Supplements notes that not every fermented food contains a probiotic with demonstrated benefit, and that viable counts can vary across products and even during storage: ODS consumer fact sheet and ODS health professional fact sheet.

Food formWhat was studiedWhy it does not generalize
Specially formulated yogurt36 women with BV drank 125 g twice daily for 4 weeks alongside metronidazole; each of four added Lactobacillus strains was specified at 107 CFU/mL PubMed trialThis was a trial product, not standard supermarket yogurt.
Live L. acidophilus yogurt46 women were enrolled, but only 7 completed the full protocol; the study used 150 mL daily PubMed trialThe small completion rate makes the finding hard to extend to everyday foods.

A review of fermented-food studies found only six clinical studies for BV and/or vulvovaginal candidiasis, and most were yogurt-based rather than fermented foods as a whole PMC review.

Diet patterns: associations exist, but they are not a prescription

Diet research is mostly observational. One systematic review found only four eligible carbohydrate studies; higher fibre was associated with less BV and higher glycaemic load with more BV, but the reviewers judged the overall risk of bias moderate to high PubMed review. Separately, a study of 1,521 women, 86% of whom were African-American, found higher fat intake associated with BV (adjusted odds ratio 1.5; 95% CI 1.1–2.4) PubMed review.

That means diet is worth reading as a background factor, not as a proven way to direct a vaginal-probiotic choice. There is no standard CFU-to-food conversion for a serving of yogurt, and no evidence that an ordinary fermented-food portion matches a studied vaginal product ODS health professional fact sheet.

Everyday habits matter more clearly than “biohacking”

The NHS advises against vaginal douching, scented vaginal products and smoking, and notes that sex or a period can be a recurrence trigger for some people NHS BV page. Those are practical habits to review before spending on another product.

Takeaway: fermented foods can be part of an ordinary diet, but the evidence is for specific study products and specific patterns of eating, not for a generic “vaginal microbiome diet.”

Are vaginal probiotics safe for everyone?

Common side effects are usually local or digestive

Across the retrieved evidence, oral live probiotics most often caused minor digestive complaints, while vaginal studies reported local effects such as discharge, odour, itching, and irritation. In the 228-person Lactin-V trial, treatment-related adverse events were reported in 87% of the probiotic group and 79% of placebo, with no severe event judged related to the study product. ODS probiotic fact sheet and Lactin-V trial

Use situationWhat the evidence saysPractical takeaway
Oral live probioticsMinor digestive symptoms are the usual issue; rare bloodstream infections have been reported, mainly in severely ill or immunocompromised people.Do not self-start without clinical advice if you are seriously ill or immunocompromised.
Vaginal live probioticsLocal irritation symptoms were reported in trials, including itching and irritation.Stop and seek advice if the product seems to worsen symptoms.
During antibiotics or antifungalsODS says these medicines might reduce the effectiveness of some probiotics.Use only as an adjunct if a clinician agrees.

Who should be cautious first

The clearest higher-risk group in the retrieved sources is people who are severely ill or immunocompromised: ODS notes rare bloodstream infections linked to probiotic use in that setting. Pregnancy also deserves caution rather than automatic self-treatment. In one trial of 320 women enrolled before 12 completed weeks of pregnancy, oral L. rhamnosus GR-1 plus L. reuteri RC-14 did not significantly improve the proportion with normal vaginal flora versus placebo. ODS probiotic fact sheet and EFFPRO pregnancy trial

For anyone with recurrent or unexplained vaginal symptoms, the safer move is diagnosis before self-treatment. The NHS advises assessment for bacterial vaginosis rather than relying on food or probiotics, and the trial evidence is too mixed to treat one product as a universal fix. NHS bacterial vaginosis guidance and BV recurrence trial

When interactions and product choice matter

Antibiotics and antifungals can matter because they may reduce the effectiveness of some live probiotics. That does not prove a dangerous drug interaction, but it does mean the timing, route, and strain need to match the studied product if a clinician recommends one. ODS also notes that there is no established probiotic upper limit, so a higher CFU number is not a safety guarantee. ODS immune function fact sheet and ODS probiotic fact sheet

Bottom line: live vaginal probiotics are not a fit-for-everyone product. The safest approach is to match the exact strain and route to the evidence, and to get medical assessment first when symptoms are recurrent, unexplained, or happening during pregnancy.

If symptoms are persistent or keep coming back, the same logic applies: repeated self-experimenting with different products is less useful than a diagnosis and a treatment plan. NHS bacterial vaginosis guidance and Lactin-V trial

Safety and precautions

Across the retrieved evidence, oral live probiotics most often caused minor digestive symptoms, while vaginal products more often caused local effects such as discharge, odour, itching or irritation. Rare bloodstream infections have been reported mainly in severely ill or immunocompromised people.

If you take medicines, especially antibiotics or antifungals, or if you are pregnant or considering use for a child, ask a healthcare professional first. Get medical advice before starting if symptoms are recurrent, unexplained or keep coming back.

Frequently asked questions

Are vaginal probiotics better taken orally or vaginally?

It depends on the exact strain and the studied product, but the route matters and oral and vaginal forms are not interchangeable. The clearest bacterial vaginosis study used a vaginal L. crispatus product, while oral products were studied separately and did not always show the same vaginal result.

What is the best probiotic strain for recurrent bacterial vaginosis?

The strongest single-trial evidence in the body is for vaginal L. crispatus CTV-05 used after metronidazole. A broader review could not identify one universal best strain, route or dose, so the best match depends on the exact studied goal.

Can probiotics for women help with yeast infections as well as bacterial vaginosis?

The certainty was low or very low and long-term benefit was unclear, so this is not a uniform finding for all products.

How long does it take for vaginal probiotics to work?

In the clearest BV study, the probiotic was used for 11 weeks, with outcomes checked by week 12 and week 24. That means timing depends on matching the studied product and schedule rather than expecting one universal timeline.

Can I use vaginal probiotics while taking antibiotics or antifungals?

Some studies used probiotics alongside metronidazole or after fluconazole, but the body also notes that antibiotics and antifungals might reduce the effectiveness of some probiotics. If a clinician recommends using them together, the strain, route and timing should match the studied product.

Are fermented foods enough, or do I need a supplement?

Fermented foods can be part of the diet, but they are not the same as a studied vaginal probiotic product. The body says not every fermented food contains a probiotic with demonstrated benefit, and there is no standard food-to-CFU conversion.

Sources

  1. Probiotics - Health Professional Fact Sheet (external link)
  2. Vaginal microbiome of reproductive-age women - PMC (external link)
  3. Probiotics - Consumer (external link)
  4. Microsoft Word - nutri120626-m _2_.doc (external link)
  5. Randomized Trial of Lactin-V to Prevent Recurrence of Bacterial Vaginosis - PMC (external link)
  6. Probiotics for the treatment of vulvovaginal candidiasis in nonpregnant women: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. (external link)
  7. Probiotics for vulvovaginal candidiasis in non-pregnant women - PubMed (external link)
  8. Effectiveness of Prophylactic Oral and/or Vaginal Probiotic Supplementation in the Prevention of Recurrent Urinary Tract Infections: A Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial - PubMed (external link)
  9. Probiotic prophylaxis in adult women with recurrent uncomplicated urinary tract infections: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials - PubMed (external link)
  10. Probiotics, a promising therapy to reduce the recurrence of bacterial vaginosis in women? a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials - PMC (external link)
  11. Augmentation of antimicrobial metronidazole therapy of bacterial vaginosis with oral probiotic Lactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1 and Lactobacillus reuteri RC-14: randomized, double-blind, placebo controlled trial. (external link)
  12. Improved treatment of vulvovaginal candidiasis with fluconazole plus probiotic Lactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1 and Lactobacillus reuteri RC-14 - PubMed (external link)
  13. Can Lactobacillus fermentum LF10 and Lactobacillus acidophilus LA02 in a slow-release vaginal product be useful for prevention of recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis?: A clinical study - PubMed (external link)
  14. Dietary Supplements for Immune Function and Infectious Diseases - Health Professional Fact Sheet (external link)
  15. Vaginal Candidiasis (external link)
  16. Efficacy of fermented foods for the prevention and treatment of bacterial vaginosis and vulvovaginal candidiasis - PMC (external link)
  17. Effect of a yoghurt drink containing Lactobacillus strains on bacterial vaginosis in women - a double-blind, randomised, controlled clinical pilot trial - PubMed (external link)
  18. Ingestion of yogurt containing Lactobacillus acidophilus compared with pasteurized yogurt as prophylaxis for recurrent candidal vaginitis and bacterial vaginosis - PubMed (external link)
  19. Carbohydrate Intake and Bacterial Vaginosis: A Systematic Review - PubMed (external link)
  20. Bacterial vaginosis - NHS (external link)
  21. Effect of probiotics on vaginal health in pregnancy. EFFPRO, a randomized controlled trial. (external link)

Read more

More in Supplements